Why hasn't my keeper got his 5th star?

[Gwyndster]

This is how I worked it out:
I read all of your workings, and everything you said about them.

Then I looked at your screencap and I worked out the averages, both for percentage and rating.

The average is weighted towards "Goalkeeping" which is why

They've go two columns for the GK attributes and they're still working it out as if there were three separate attribute columns, rather than 2+1.

Where you used to have 3 colums:

Attack; Defence; Physical

You now have
Goalkeeping 1; Goalkeeping 2; Physical and Mental.

You cannot work your average out accurately if you treat it as 2 equal halves.

1: Goalkeeping; 2: Physical and Mental

Because 2/3 of the figures that make up the average are in one category. "Goalkeeping".

You have 15 attributes:

10 in "Goalkeeping"
Reflexes 74%
Agility 73%
Anticipation 72%
Rushing Out 72%
Communication73%
Throwing 72%
Kicking 73%
Punching 72%
Aerial Reach 73%
Concentration 72%

5 in Physical and Mental
Fitness 86%
Strength 88%
Aggression 89%
Speed 84%
Creativity 88%
Total 1161
Divided by 15 attributes = average of 77.4