Exactly the same happened to me last night, same result 4-3 win on penalties and then nothing until the morning when we got second place.

Out of interest, did they miss their 3rd penalty and your keeper save the 5th?

Having read that the exact same scenario occurred to other people, it makes me question how many results are a foregone conclusion.
Click image for larger version.  Name: assoc eff up 2.JPG  Views: 81  Size: 48.0 KB  ID: 83393Click image for larger version.  Name: assoc eff up.JPG  Views: 79  Size: 41.4 KB  ID: 83394Click image for larger version.  Name: Lies 2.JPG  Views: 79  Size: 18.5 KB  ID: 83395Click image for larger version.  Name: Lies.JPG  Views: 79  Size: 25.4 KB  ID: 83396Click image for larger version.  Name: reactions edited.jpg  Views: 76  Size: 72.1 KB  ID: 83397