3-1-4-1-1 beats 4-5-1 V

Hi, today I was playing against some opponent with 3-1-4-1-1 formation so put 4-5-1 V because i saw people recommend it against 3-1-4-1-1 but I lost :( . The result was 1:0 for him. So should I keep this formation or there is a better one? :confused:

Here is the opponent tactic nad players...
Attachment 11880 Attachment 11881

And here is my tactic and players.
Attachment 11883 Attachment 11882

In the first game he had better statistics and a lot of chances. It wasn't easy win for him but he did won.
My players blocked many attacks but they couldn't get to his goal :p