Illegal

Is this formation illegal? Attachment 14866

Seems fine to me. Got 3 defenders, flankers and at least 3 midfielders.

Looks ok to me

I agree with meis and Cat Harrison, this formations seems fine.

ok, thanks

...-.-''' xD

there seems to be strong wind from the east ... seriously affecting coordination and positioning of midfield players xD

Attachment 14909
Is this legal??

Brunny, the formation is "legal" and won't get a possession penalty, but there are players not in their correct position for their role, this can also affect possession but not as bad as a penalty for illegal formation. The guys OOP might also have their morale/rating affected.

Both my dc and mr just resume training after injuries that is why some player are in the wrong position but would it better to put a 5*st than 4*mr...my st contribute more assist than the mr himself in the recent match..but which is better a good player on wrong position or weak player on his own position??

I have played guys 1 spot OOP (out of position) successfully but it seems for most if you move them too far they do not do well. So it's try and see what happens.. I would go for the ST too I think