Big goalie debate - help ?

Hi Guys,

I have a #18 Goalie (One on One Shot Stopper) who has been letting in zero goals in League - he is retiring.

I have a #29 Goalie ( Penalty Kick Specialist ) who has been letting in 1 goal on average in cup and challenge games.

I know I should be happy with this but am wondering why (besides the tougher competition in the cups) it seems my One on One three star goalie "seems to be" out performing PK five star goalie and was even thinking of using him for some big games coming up instead of the five star as I am better on D the offense.

I don't want to make a huge mistake here so does anyone have any preferences in Goalie types for Big Games and do you prefer a pk specialist (29) over a one on one shot stopper (18) and why ?

Any thoughts on this would be huge and appreciated,

Thanks my friends,
Flying V

Play the better goal keeper, fill up his fitness and morale, he should be fine.