Since it looks like the token raffle suggestion is a failure, I had another suggestion.

Scratch Cards - I would do it on a basis where everyone is a winner so you wouldn't get ripped off.

Scratch Cards could be optional and cost say 5 tokens each. There could be many prizes.

Basic Prizes (Most likely outcome of prizes, 82% Chance) (Worth 5 Tokens)
5 Red Medic Boosters
5 Green Rest Boosters
5 Blue Morale Boosters
5 Tokens
In Game $ (Amount Recieved is Proportional to Manager Level)
A choice of a basic logo or jersey

Medium Prizes (10% Chance) (Worth 10 Tokens)
10 Red Medic Boosters
10 Green Rest Boosters
10 Blue Morale Boosters
10 Tokens
2x the amount of In Game $ from basic prizes

Good Prizes (5% Chance) (Worth 25 Tokens)
25 Red Medic Boosters
25 Green Rest Boosters
25 Blue Morale Boosters
25 Tokens
5x the amount of In Game $ from basic prizes
A choice of a Premium Logo (30 Tokens)

Best Prizes (2% Chance) (Worth at least 50 Tokens)
50 Red Medic Boosters
50 Green Rest Boosters
50 Blue Morale Boosters
50 Tokens
10x the amount of In Game $ from basic prizes
A choice of any player from the scout

Jackpot Prizes (1% Chance) (Worth 100 Tokens)
100 Tokens
A Choice of 2 players from the scout
Official Club Logos and Jerseys

Doesn't sound too bad if you compare it to the raffle.