Freshmeat the same has just happened to me i'm top of the league i just played a team i've beaten before both teams had the same formation in previous game when i beat him his player ratings 16 mine is 26.
i had 70% possesion he had 30% i had most shots at goal and on target. yet i got beat 3-1 . i had 3 bookings in 1 game all miss the next league game. funny thing is since i gave the players increased bonuses they seem to have struggled the last couple of games.