Hmm, that is weird.

You actually should be winning, your formation is legal and your team is great. It looks like you're just getting trolled by the engine.

Try changing your formation and/or your arrows, it could be that your team can't play that formation (i.e your team does not like playing 4-1-4-1) or your midfield players are way too offensive. You could also try changing the options (i.e trying offensive, normal or defensive) or something else.