Better Player

I want an advice.

Which of this two is better

Player 1 - Position Striker - Quality 36 - Offensive movements 50
Player 2 - Position Striker - Quality 40 - Offensive movements 43

I know player 2 has better quality and stars, but player 1 is better as a Striker,
because he has 50 in all attackig attributes.

So, i don't know what is better...

Please help!!

Thanks for your help!

For me the first is a unbalanced player, is only good on His on position, for example If you whant to press all field, he do not have defensive skills for that.
But to say more we need to know age and market value.

Thanks for your answer.

I post the age and market value,

First Player - Age:25 - Value: 1.94
Second Player - Age: 26 - Value: 2.43M+

Thanks in advance