Printable View
I have decided to tank this season. So I was training all my players to condition zero, placed my 2nd team in wrong positions and ofcourse eligal formation!
I loose, big surprice, 0-5.
3 of my players got rating 8, and rest 7!?!? Wtf.
I have search in this forum, and does not find anything about this wierd rating system.
Thx
There are already complains about rating system, you are not alone. But I don't think Nordeus care bout user concerns at all.
I've been here for over a year now, and have never taken any notice of either the player ratings or the after match stats. Neither have any logic to them. Just play the game as if they weren't there.
as above, as long as i`m winning or losing if tanking like you nothing matter`s till Nordeus pulls their finger out and explain and improve
A GK who concedes 7 goals gets 8 rating along with all the defenders getting 8. Now tell!!!!
Considering you tell your GK before the game to let them all in...this is not surprising. He has to make it look good ya know!Quote:
Originally Posted by Saransh Vatsa
But it wasn't my keeper, it was my opponents whom I thrashed last season. He got 8 rating and all the defenders in his team too got 8 while my striker who scored 4 got 7. MoM was my AMC with 2 goals and a assist.Quote:
Originally Posted by cracicot
this wasnt directed at you, it was directed at all who tank.Quote:
Originally Posted by Saransh Vatsa
I know that it wasn't directed to me and I also spoke in general. Nothing against u, believe me.Quote:
Originally Posted by cracicot
P.S I am also Tanking..... :D :cool:
I have 2 tanking accounts and I agree with you, they are tanking and getting loads of 7's and 8's for ratings.
http://i44.tinypic.com/2eprb6u.png
I go with this formation, lost 0-9 last night and got fair ratings. The other tank account, same thing.
Your players is slow training with all that skills. But if you not are suposed to get SA OR POS.. Its ok
Dude, I have no clue who you are referring to, but if you are talking about the screenshot of my lvl 8 account, then I would love you know how you can justify that statement.Quote:
Originally Posted by Anders Bjerregaard
But let me help you: I am not a token buyer and I am only starting to tank seasons to build up players. As I have a full crew of 22 players, it is very very expensive to buy 18yo fast trainers. Because of that, I have to use medium trainers. buying the 18yo fast trainer is like buying a younger scout and is rare for this account. I tend to favour my lvl 9 account with the Liverpool jerseys and am tanking that season as well so my guys will be 5-6* for the end of next season.
But if you are talking about some other team in this thread, sorry for disturbing you. Frankly, I re-read your post a few times, and I am still not sure what you mean.
players younger than me though, the more that I have been removed from the CUP. wtf?? confusing!
Attachment 13700
Check out the screenshot. I won the game 4-0. I have 2 players on 8 and rest of them 7. Opponent has 5 players on rating 8 and all of them defense players and the gk. lol
I am starting to believe that this is the most unrealistic football management game of all times.
Looking at your screenshot, I think the ratings could be pretty accurate. You won 4-0, but your team looks far superior to your opponents. Maybe their defenders played really well to keep the score down to just four.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ahmet Aygun
Don't do this to me my friend. I won the game 4-0 and my team totals 72 out of 110 on ratings. Oppenent looses 4-0 and his team gets 79 out of 110. On rating basis he played better than me and still loose the game 4-0:confused: Also on stats it says 2 saves for his GK. His GK concedes 4 and saves 2 and still get 8 on rating? I totaled 19 shots and 10 of them on target. That is a neat-work for his defense to get 8? More than %50 of my shots are on target and %40 shooting efficiency; and his defense played better than my strikers?Quote:
Originally Posted by Raykco
If those stats are accurate I rest my case.
But the stats aren't accurate. They never are. And hardly ever make any sense.
Thats what we are talking about in this thread, but it was you who saidQuote:
Originally Posted by Raykco
Quote:
Originally Posted by Raykco
I think we are mixing up RATINGS and STATS here. It's the stats that usually don't make any sense. True, the ratings are not always truly fair, but what I first meant was that maybe their defenders had a really good match for their quality, whereas although your strikers did well to score 4, maybe they should have got many more. You say that you had 10 shots on target, but you only scored 4 times. Therefore his defence must have stopped at least another 6 goalbound shots. That's what I meant by them playing well.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ahmet Aygun
I think many aspects of this game doesn't make any sense. But imo if anything is more accurate; stats are more accurate than ratings. Your opinion could be different than mine that is ok.Quote:
Originally Posted by Raykco
But no defense deserves good ratings; if their team concedes 4 goals. And as I wrote 10 out of my 19 shots finds its target. If that would be like 4 out of 19 shots and all of them would have been converted to a goal; than I could say that the defense played better but the GK was in his bad day. But for the stats like 10 out of 19 shots on target; I can't say his defense and GK are on their good day. At least I don't want them in my team after watching a 4-0 game on this circumstnaces. Anyway what are we discussing? We are trying to give meaning to one of the most unlogical football manager game in history.
