not sure why some people believe 4-4-2 formations are unbeatable while the same people say this game is completely random. I'm playing 442 and I'm facing the same problems as you guys do, meaning troll results... Over 4 seasons, I won the league 3 times, the CL 1 time and never won the cup. The biggest reason would be that I got the highest quality team, imo
This year, I was defeated by a team with 14 Q less than my team... and that was an abandoned team.
Have fun ! it's just a free game !