Transfer Negotiations ?

[dicky]

so i completely forgot about the transfer negotiation as i normal play using my android phone...
but recently due to work somehow unblocking Facebook i use the desktop app more which is miles better btw.

i kept receiving no token offers from the 3 same Asian players... kept rejecting them but still kept offering the same no token low value offer lol. In the end i just waited out the 24hours and they stopped bidding...

Sooooo my point lol...

it got me thinking bout the system... on my server i can get a nordgen player..mid season for about 20/30 tokens if I'm up against someone determined, if i'm lucky ill pick them up for a couple of tokens...if no one bids or get some guy bid once or twice and leave which happens alot for some reason?

so what's an offer people would accept?

i currently have put two offers in for players as experiment...
i personally wouldn't pay more than 25 tokens as i can get a nordgen for that or much less...
so the guy will get 8 tokens and money... to him that might be stupid but to me there is no point giving more

so i think maybe nordeus need to take less tokens from the transfer or revise the system as just doesnt seem to work that well?

im lv17 non token buyer
and when i say nordgen i mean 18yr old 4 or 9 ending

[Sherifon]

well, 5 tokens for the manager is good enough so your 25 tokens offer is very good already because he will get 8 not 5 but sometimes the manager refuses your offer because he need the player badly and sometime manager don't see offers if they are not active daily.
that's my opinion.

[Wierdo]

The whole transfer negotiations system is a complete waste of time. You should be able to adjust the ratio of money/tokens. But you can only offer tokens if you pay more than the market value. To offer somebody a decent amount of tokens you have to pay waaaaay above the market value. Why would anybody do that? To offer somebody say 10 tokens for a player you'd have to pay out nearly 30 tokens and several million above the market value in cash. At that point, you may as well buy a scout instead. At least then you won't pay more than the market value for the player.

I've just put in a no token offer for a player to see what happens. I'm sure it will get rejected. It's for a position I want, but I checked the players stats and the last 4 games he's scored 5 and picked up a current red card. So it's clear why teh seller is getting rid. But I'll try and sign him to see if I can get him playing well. I've offered market value and no tokens. But I bet the seller doesn't accept the offer. He'll then put the player on the market where he might well get less than market value. So I think my offer is reasonable.

[dicky]

i said he would get 8 token

today i just got 2 nordgen players for 4 tokens lol.

the transfer system needs to change its pointless imo and doesnt get used. why pay 25/30 tokens when you can get them for much less...

[spornybol]

some market`s are different, on mine you get nutter`s that go 25/30 rounds s can be cheaper via neg list, each server is different

[Sherifon]

yeah, I like negotiations because I hate bid wars and bid wars happens alot on nordgens at my server.

[paul northey]

on my server it is getting more difficult to get nordgens and any decent young players so i have turned to neg list and if your getting the player you want whats 11 or 12 tokens.

[Cat Harrison]

I tend to accept the offer if they offer 3 or 4 Tokens, but then I only allow guys that I *want* to sell to sit with a point shy of a star to put them on the list. Some managers don't intend their player to be on the list and won't sell.

[dave1311]

I had a lucky escape in negotiations as last season I was offered a wad of cash and tokens for one of my under-performing scout ST. He was warming the bench as he couldn't hit a barn door. However this season he is scoring goals for fun and currently league top scorer. So glad I kept hold of him. My advice is to beware of negotiations because you might be selling a future gem.

[paul northey]

or buying one.