For now, the game looks more like on playback. You can have the controller in hand, press on whatever buttons you want, it is not going to change the final outcome because you are watching like a pre-recorded match (or like you are trying to change the outcome of a non-live match that you are watching by doing things, thinking that is it actually being played live). I have done several tests lately (being as manager of both teams playing against each other). There were 4 matches that resulted in penalty shoot-outs; in all of them the players shoot to the left bottom side of the GK.