If there's anything that this FA fiasco has taught me, statistics do not matter.

Printable View

03-04-2017
axd23

1 Attachment(s)

If there's anything that this FA fiasco has taught me, statistics do not matter.

So I just played for the FA 3rd/4th place Finals.

Attachment 78530

With these statistics I should be winning or getting a draw at least, not losing 3-0.

Why did this happen?

Because the opponent is 23 levels higher than me.

Statistics don't matter.
Good or bad day doesn't matter.

Too bad I didn't start the game in 2011 because I thought the game was too weak to compare to FM.

Punish me for that...
03-04-2017
talisman

2 Attachment(s)

...neither do the AM comments...

I have NEVER been beaten so badly playing 4-5-1V against any formation where the starting XI qualities have been so even. And the ratings are a joke. That front 3 has destroyed defences of Level+1 teams up to 12%Q better this season.

Attachment 78537 Attachment 78538
03-04-2017
Cloverfield

quoting my/the same opinion.

I feel a bit disappointed if indeed this is the case :(

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cloverfield

Interesting stuff can be retrieved by this bug and the game engine.
I observed something odd.
I was the unlucky one to be in a very low level (L5) playing against 15+ level manager.
So the % difference is huge.

Despite the difference my stats were not bad. Too many shots in general and many on target. I just COULD NOT score and oppo scored ..a lot
Also the possession was equal. For such great difference only 80-20 would be expected.

So, I try to extract some info from it.
The bug affects the quality of team and not the statistics.
So even the statistics are "politically correct" the game engine does other calculation and creates a winner.

So...
SHOULD WE TRUST THE STATISTICS? :confused:

Till now I relied toο much on them, but this bug maybe opened a pointless tactic view of the game :confused:
03-04-2017
axd23

2 Attachment(s)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cloverfield

quoting my/the same opinion.

I feel a bit disappointed if indeed this is the case :(

My semi-finals yesterday against a manager 11 levels higher than me to further prove your point.

Attachment 78539

Attachment 78540
03-04-2017
Shire

Simular experience yesterday. Faced a team 15% worse than me that didnt watch any of the two games.
He won the shots in both games, 6-0 total in goals. My 140% offensive scoring a fantastic zero goals in 180 minutes of simulation.

Ive won the treble for the third season in a row so im not terrible by any means. Game just decided i was gonna get mindsmacked.
03-04-2017
forzautreg

3 Attachment(s)

this was me weekend

Attachment 78547 Attachment 78548 Attachment 78549

me team ac milan in al the games most possesion but al the games lose
03-04-2017
Shire

Just lost in FA again in final against a 15% weaker team.

Score? 6-0. Did the game bug out or what?
03-04-2017
talisman

2 Attachment(s)

Second match in Associations. Same teams, same Quality, same scoreline. The Rats had more possession in this match, but still wasn't able to convert this to goals on the board - not even a consolation. The 80-goal front three were rendered mere incompetents, Patrick Tillmanns registering another hat-trick, this time of shots ballooned over the bar, and Kostadin Marinov succeeding in evading defenders only to run into the 'keeper - several times. And as for the AM BS - words fail me...

Attachment 78562 Attachment 78564
03-04-2017
ronnymvc

1 Attachment(s)

excuse me guys ...my FA( and not) only can not even score a goal in 12 games lol ... what is that big ****?
Attachment 78574
03-04-2017
nikolgiorgos

We have this situation with the asso bug this weekend.
What's the point of make critics for this part of the game procedure under these circumstances.
03-04-2017
axd23

Quote:

Originally Posted by nikolgiorgos

We have this situation with the asso bug this weekend.
What's the point of make critics for this part of the game procedure under these circumstances.

Of course I'm going to criticize the game when statistics don't count for the outcome of a match. What's the point of playing or even trying then?

And of course It takes away every realistic aspect of the game.
03-04-2017
axd23

Anyway, I would like you Nik to lock the thread please.
03-04-2017
Cloverfield

Quote:

Originally Posted by axd23

Of course I'm going to criticize the game when statistics don't count for the outcome of a match. What's the point of playing or even trying then?

And of course It takes away every realistic aspect of the game.

+1

It is a different discussion.
Code may have broken iN certain parts but it did not totally collapse.

And the indication we have is that the statistics are randomly displayed.
03-04-2017
Shire

Quote:

Originally Posted by nikolgiorgos

We have this situation with the asso bug this weekend.
What's the point of make critics for this part of the game procedure under these circumstances.

Asso bug?
For us that never heard of it, care to explain or link me?
03-04-2017
nikolgiorgos

read this
https://forum.topeleven.com/bugs-tec...%EF%BC%9F.html

Quote:

Code may have broken iN certain parts but it did not totally collapse.

of course in asso games of this w-e the code was collapse.
Try to have conclusions from a game stats between two teams with 20 levels difference ?

anyway, it's more constructive trying to find hints, to understand the game better, in normal games
than those asso matches.

Quote:

Anyway, I would like you Nik to lock the thread please.

as you wish