For me it all depends on whether it's easy to find fast trainer. The fact that you get the player on season day 1 is great and I would be willing to overspend if that saves me a lot of time in auctions to find a fast trainer for the right position.
A 2 star fast trainer youth guy would be fine for me. Makes not a huge difference if you start 2 star or 3 star, few more packs but better player at the end.