Tackles and fouls, plus defensive mentality with short pass and no counter will give you a decent amount of possesion. Also with the amount of shoot he had but small possesion diference proves me right, he (Scab) was playing attacking but is useless if the other team is defending well. It would be best if he changed to normal or even defensive mentality to give room for his attackers to surprise him in counter and probably would took 3 goals.Of course that with more details we could dig deeper the causes.