Sometime it is not about having the highest skilled players, it's all about combating your opponents formation to minimise his effectiveness whilst maximising your own threat.
From what I see if you are 8 skill points ahead of him playing a low skilled player in one position will not hurt, also the game engine often rewards lower skilled players with better performances when up against a higher skilled player.

As smoggie has said with the players you have play the V if you do not fancy that, your only other options are 4-3-3, 4-1-4-2 or match him with 4-4-2 with man on man marking.