UPDATE: Managed to win, 4-3 at penalty shoot-outs, 0-0 the score at the end of extra time. Went with Potemy's suggestion, which is how I usually play, only I used blue arrow on AMC to support mid. Short passing through the middle seemed to work well, had a lot of possesion, but my STs missed a lot of chances, they've all been pretty much useless all season long.