well you can try your luck .. your worry should be if you want to push it to penalties, he has a penalty stopper ... so you need to win it in normal time, i may use defensive/counter attack, but will add 2 strikers to have better chance of scoring
I would had played
.....CB......CB......CB
.........DM......DM.....
...RM.......CM......LM
..........ST.... ST.....
his fullbacks are great so not sure if you should go with focus passing to flankes or focus in mix or in mid.. .. i normally try them during the game and see which one works better and stick to it
or go with this one
.RB......CB......CB....LB
.........DM......DM.....
..........CM...CM.......
..........ST.... ST.....
all attack in mid, and concentrate your attack to have numbers .. beside defend him better as his attacking in middle too