Printable View
I just add skill points to my players according to the position they play.....
example ;- if its a striker then i concentrate on attacking and occasionally physical and mental but would never touch defending skills. Vice versa for a defender ...
now i have striker (19 yrs old)with
attack -28.6
p&m-24
defence-16
is it a good strategy ?
How do you spread points for each of the following :-
Strikers ---
AMC-----
MC----
Defenders-
wingers---
Gk-------
is this a wrong forum to put this thread should i open this in another forum?
Is the right section but you should be a bit more patient :D
Strikers Attack
AMC Attack
MC Attack
Defenders - def
wingers Attack
Gk def
as simple as that :)
When you have 20 SP of difference between two specs, you can't train more your highest one. In that case, you must train the lowest one to "reopen" the highest one.
I don't know.Quote:
Originally Posted by FC Barcelona
If you don't train p&m a striker will never be fast.
Also mc are supposed to have some defensive skills.
Don't know..
True, but i want to push my players and train them on their main skill :) If each player do his job, no need to have versatile players :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Carlitos
A quick exemple : My messi is my best striker. He's 36 quality and have 42.6 attack and 33.4 Physical & mental. Neymar is only 30 quality, but have 40.8 attack, 30 phy. When messi have 32.4 in defense, Neymar have only 20.8. But believe it or not, Neymar is the perfect backup for Messi, he has never disappointed me :)
But that's my way to train them, you don't have to do the same buddy :)
Well I got your point, in someway make sense.Quote:
Originally Posted by FC Barcelona
I will try with one player to see what happens.
I go auto.
Is that a bad idea specially when good skills are spread all over the three categories.
Totally agree with this, i train my midfield and strikers in the attack skills, vice versa for DMC, defenders and GK.Quote:
Originally Posted by FC Barcelona
Really bad. The engine will try to balance your skillsQuote:
Originally Posted by Wildinho
Yeah but how would you want a good striker without him having heading & positioning ?!!!!Quote:
Originally Posted by FC Barcelona
And since you cant address those without defense as a whole then you will eventually balance all three skills categories.
The point is, you will have to train defense unless you have 20 SP of difference between the highest and the lowest skill, so don't you prefer to have a goleador during the defense training? :pQuote:
Originally Posted by Wildinho
I think a maximum skilled player is more effective than a mid-skilled player :)
its always good to have balanced players, there are important skills in Defense for Attackers, and important skills for Defenders under Attack...
I think it depends of your tactic. Let the player do their job :) btw, train them like you want to, as i said before, that's my way of training them and i do love it, you don't have to follow it :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Pupack
I wish if we can address each skill on its own.
yup that's what i was thinking And i had done a experiment i added defensive skills to one of my striker and didn't add any defensive skills to my another striker ..played both of them in same matches and coincidently both were on same skill(almost) and at the end of entire season I found the Striker whose defensive skill's were upgraded scored more headers than the other . ( i was present in 90% of games)
I was asking myself this question during the week and thought to comr to the forums to find out if anyone had discussed it at any time. Like most good ideas, I put to the back of my to-do list, where most things get done eventually. lol
Just a day or two ago I observed that most, if not all, of the players on the scout list had almost equal in all three areas of training, barring a point or three between specs. IE, att 35, def 33, p&m 34 for a striker for example.
However, I have since realised that it doesn't matter how the skill points are distributed, as the player quality will rise however the skill points are distributed.
In my opinion a well rounded player is better, but I think it is important to train a player in accordance with any special ability that he might have. No point in training a player with one-one scorer in defence for example, (if that is indeed possible). :)
i had a striker with : 30 defense / 50 attack / 46 mental and he was scoring a lot with header from corners ... so i don`t really believe what is saying there ...Quote:
Originally Posted by Wildinho
personally I like to keep it balanced, I think there are qualities in defense that attackers need also like Heading and defenders need quite decent Passing, so for example if my ST has 60 in attack I let him have around 55 in physical & mental and 45-50~ in defense. same with DC just switching between attack and defense. the MC I keep really balanced with say 60 attack, 57~ physical and mental and 57~ defense. for GK I have 60 defense, 60 physical and mental and 50~ attack.
I have a question about skill points. If I got some players with skill points without assign, at the end of the season they will be lost???
I believe so. Use them before the season starts. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by antoniolio
Not so. I deliberately kept skill points unassigned last term (so as to hopefully get an easier league allocation) and they carry over.Quote:
Originally Posted by El Pistolero
What for a goalkeeper ? Defence or P&M?