Team Percent

Hello. I have written to you many times about the problem with the percentage of my team.

So. At the moment my team
protection - 100.9%, midfield - 99.8%, attack - 108%.
**That is, the average percentage should be 100.9 + 99.8 + 108 = 308.7 / 3 = 102.9%
And I have now 96.6%.

For example, the team "Terra" with which the match after 30 minutes.

He has a defense of 86%, midfield 87.4%, attack 81.6%

average - - 86 + 87.4 + 81.6 = 255/3 = 85%
Now he has 86.5%

Please, refuse.
And the answer can this error influence the outcome of the match?

Thank you in advance
Team - Zamotable FC
Manager - Saka Salada
Email - kartashyan84@gmail.com

Attachment 95313

Email - kartashyan84@gmail.com

The way the team quality is calculated has changed, there are plenty of posts on the forum, people have been talking all week.

Hey Saka Salada, KenoticFC is correct. The way quality is calculated has changed with the idea of keeping the information about consistent throughout all competition formats. Check this thread from SaucyFC for details.

both are wrong answers

The pic we see it's the only screen left in the game that shows the real quality of two teams (the q of current 11th squads).
The problem with that screen is that we don't know exactly how it calculates and compare the quality.
For example it considers the quality of the GK for defense q.
It considers the quality of a DMC in the defense and in the middle area.
It considers the quality of AMs in attack and in the mdf.
But we don't know how much - never explained.

Anyway, the calculation of adding those three qualities and then /3 is wrong.

and to give an example with pics

I have a team with avg quality (best 14 players) 137%
This is the screen were we (still) can see the quality of the players in the field
* but remember, it's a mix of zones/players , it's not only my 4 defenders that give the percentage of defense !

Attachment 95327

Those are the 14 (+1) best players
Attachment 95328

Now I use most of my worst players
Attachment 95329

and here how comes this comparison (while the main screen still shows us the best 14 quality)
Attachment 95330

jesus niko, that is a team of old age pensioners hahahahaha

yes, I have them maybe a year :o
staying in the same lv, playing only for asso

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nikolgiorgos

yes, I have them maybe a year :o
staying in the same lv, playing only for asso

---

ahhhh you little tanker you. great example set by a moderator lol

yes, I used every legit tactic the game permits you to do :o
for having fun

I'll use your own shot for my explanation Niko.

(1) Top half of the comparison screen shows the squad's strength (aka Quality), based on the top 14 players of the team in question. It's the average of their combined quality. This way you can judge what kind of team you're facing.

(2) Bottom half of the comparison screen shows the Defence, Midfield, Attack capabilities of a team's current setup. It's based on the 11 players present in the team's current line-up (starting 11). This way you can judge what're the capabilities of the opponent with his/her current player setup.

Attachment 95355

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jeeves

I'll use your own shot for my explanation Niko.

(1) Top half of the comparison screen shows the squad's strength (aka Quality), based on the top 14 players of the team in question. It's the average of their combined quality. This way you can judge what kind of team you're facing.

(2) Bottom half of the comparison screen shows the Defence, Midfield, Attack capabilities of a team's current setup. It's based on the 11 players present in the team's current line-up (starting 11). This way you can judge what're the capabilities of the opponent with his/her current player setup.

Attachment 95355

---

so then explain to me why my TOP 14 players average is 120.4% but yet when i go to my league and click another team to compare it shows my average team quality is 122.7% ??? how is that even possible ???

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Richie72

Snip*

---

This happens because you're opening the Manager Profile comparison screen. That screen hasn't been updated with the "Top 14 Players" change. That screen will start calculating average team quality like the rest of the game once we push out the next Top 11 release.

And I do know that this can indeed be confusing for the time being. :(

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jeeves

This happens because you're opening the Manager Profile comparison screen. That screen hasn't been updated with the "Top 14 Players" change. That screen will start calculating average team quality like the rest of the game once we push out the next Top 11 release.

And I do know that this can indeed be confusing. :(

---

and all i know is, why complicate a simple issue. why fix something that isn't broken ? the devs seem to have too much time on their hands. perhaps they should focus on serious bugs like pen shoot out issues in asso games !!!!

Jeeves, I still don't understand how those qualities of zones come (that was the first question of the post) and that what has to do with the update of best 14.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jeeves

I'll use your own shot for my explanation Niko.

(1) Top half of the comparison screen shows the squad's strength (aka Quality), based on the top 14 players of the team in question. It's the average of their combined quality. This way you can judge what kind of team you're facing.

(2) Bottom half of the comparison screen shows the Defence, Midfield, Attack capabilities of a team's current setup. It's based on the 11 players present in the team's current line-up (starting 11). This way you can judge what're the capabilities of the opponent with his/her current player setup.

Attachment 95355

---

(1) This is untrue - It is NOT the quality of your top 14 rated players added together and divided by 14. If that were the case then my selected 11 and highest quality 3 substitutes = an average quality of (1168 [the 11 selected players] + 290 [total of my 3 highest quality substitutes] = 1458 divided by 14) = 104.14. It shows as 104.8 in my comparison screen. As an aside if I take my selected 11 players alone (as per the old way) then their average quality is 1168 divided by 11 = 106.18.

(2) Given the breakdown as shown above my team actually appears with DEFENCE 105.8 - MIDFIELD 106.4 - ATTACK 106.6.

I have added the defensive skills of my 10 selected players together with the 3 highest quality subs defensive skills (can't count GK as they have no skills showing other than "Physical") and it comes to 1424. Divide that by 13 and my average Defensive skills for my team and 3 subs is 109.53.
It is not possible to do this for Midfield as skills do not show against players for Midfield.
Following the same principal with the attacking skills of my 10 selected players and 3 highest quality subs attacking skills (again cannot count GK) and it comes to 1363. Divide by 13 and my average Attacking skills is 104.84.

These figures are very different to those showing in (2) above.

The only explanation I can think of is that for the purpose of this game the skills listed for each player in their left hand skills column relates to DEFENCE, the middle column relates to ATTACK and the right column (described as Physical) relates to MIDFIELD and that this is not made clear to the players of the game. If it were made clear how this new formula works then the players of the game (me included) would be able to work out how much we needed to strengthen our defence, attack or midfield depending on what we worked out.

Why oh Why can't TopX1 actually explain to us exactly what calculations they have used so we can accurately decide where we need to strengthen our teams in the transfer market !!

Hopeless - None of this makes sense !

Just read your next comment below about you've only done half a job ! I find that difficult to believe that you would do half a bodge job rather than wait until the whole package was ready to be rolled out. Shockingly bad !