Cheater?

[Siddas]

So from the first post image
can someone tell me who is the better striker?
I know one is 26 years and the other is 20
but lets say they are both 26 years of age.

Luke McGuniess has a quality of 85%
David Osmon has a quality of 99%

Osmon is a better overall player on paper as his attributes are evenly spread.
Yet McGuiness kicks ass on most skill points so on attacking skills is he a better striker?


Does quality over rule skill or does Skills over rule Quality
who is the best striker on them stats if both were the same age?

Just asking as i have a striker who has great skills but he's 119%. 30% lower than my current number 9 but his shooting and finishing are not so far apart from his..