Has the formations and tactics engine changed for 4-5-1 V?

[CIBlue]

It used to be that 4-5-1 V would beat 4=4=2 classic, and 4-1-2-1-2 ND would beat 4-5-1 V, but I've been seeing differently this season.

In my league I've seen a team using 4=4=2 classic beat a team of equal or slightly better quality using 4-5-1 V. This was on 4 different occasions.

I have also seen many teams using 4-1-2-1-2 ND losing against a team of equal or slightly worse quality using 4-5-1 V. Also some teams using 4-1-2-1-2 ND barely beating a team of significantly worse quality using 4-5-1 V.

Anyone notice this or have thoughts about it?

[Croft Original]

Yes some of the counter formations are becoming redundant, but the logic is still there I think.

[Abdullah Sarfaraz]

I don't think so...

[ilham11]

It used to be that 4-5-1 V would beat 4=4=2 classic, and 4-1-2-1-2 ND would beat 4-5-1 V, but I've been seeing differently this season.

In my league I've seen a team using 4=4=2 classic beat a team of equal or slightly better quality using 4-5-1 V. This was on 4 different occasions.

I have also seen many teams using 4-1-2-1-2 ND losing against a team of equal or slightly worse quality using 4-5-1 V. Also some teams using 4-1-2-1-2 ND barely beating a team of significantly worse quality using 4-5-1 V.

Anyone notice this or have thoughts about it?

i agree with you bro.

[Eugen Cristea]

[QUOTE=CIBlue;150584I have also seen many teams using 4-1-2-1-2 ND losing against a team of equal or slightly worse quality using 4-5-1 V. Also some teams using 4-1-2-1-2 ND barely beating a team of significantly worse quality using 4-5-1 V.

Anyone notice this or have thoughts about it?[/QUOTE]

The 4-5-1 V-style was a counter to ND, so it's not strange.
It doesn't work (for me) anymore, so i use 3-5-2 V against ND now.

I've seen people complaining about the V-style, recently.
I looks like in your server it still works, as a counter to ND, but it doesn't as a counter to 4-4-2(not for a couple of seasons now).

[renovo]

but it doesn't as a counter to 4-4-2(not for a couple of seasons now).

strange coz I never lost against 4-4-2 using 4-1-5V even it were few times better teams