One more thing I've learnt on the forum and have had success with it you're playing attacking mentality but still asking your players to counter ? Counter attack means you let the other team attack so you hit them on the counter so maybe it would work better with normal mentality also pressing whole pitch works better with offside trap and pressing own half works better with counter
I usually play normal mentality pressing whole pitch cause then you make less mistakes than playing attacking mentality since pressing whole pitch is already risky by pressing everywhere on the field more chances for the other team to counter and you're being out of position just an opinion good luck