OK so far I have had the options you have given me are

5-3-1-1 - with defensive, counter, long pass mixed. Arrow on your AMC and 2 sided MCs.
4-1-4-1 - defensive, long balls, counters, mixed focus.
4-1-2-1-2 - blue arrow on both dc and dmc man on man
4-3W-1-2 - Counter/Normal depending on your strength, Mixed focus, mixed passing style, normal tackling, whole pitch press

Any other suggestions from the crowd here? I really need to beat him to win the league