I know that you are missing another DMC and another AMC, I was thinking two DMC's will provide double coverage against his ST's, 1 MR and 1 ML to provide single coverage against his DMR and DML, 2 AMC's to provide support to your 1 ST.

You could also try 3142, 3 DC's, 1 DMC with red arrow to support your Midfielders, arrows up on your MR and ML. Still force counter to get him to come out and make mistakes with , press your own half, normal tackling, normal mentality, focus passing mixed and mixed passing.

I get that this could be risky but sometimes you have to gamble a bit. My emergency formation would be 424.

ST ST
AMR AML arrows up
MC MC
DL DC DC DR

Attacking or hard attacking, normal or hard tackle, passing long, pressing the whole pitch, no force counter, off side trap on, if you have faster defenders, focus passing mixed.

But that is just me, him leading 2:0 does not mean the end.