4-5-1 V-Style does not work against 4-4-2!!!

I did won the first match 1-0 (my Quality 30, he was 17) !!!

Second match he did won 2:1 !

All my players are from scout! I win against Quality 38 (im 30) but can't win (Q17) 4-4-2 with 4-5-1 V-Style!
Nothing wrong on my tactics, i always change them in game to bring some dynamics, i nearly never lose...

I bet, if i would play ANY OTHER Formation, i would have won !