I'd play Hexagon
DL-DC-DC-DR
--MC--MC--
AML----AMR
--ST--ST--
Blue arrows on the DCs, either mixed or down the flank passing. Half press, leave offsides/counter off. Add red arrows to the attacking wings in the 2nd half if you need goals, maybe going to long ball & counter (note, as you have no away goals you want to stop him scoring any)