How to win against 3W-5N-2

It's a cup game 2nd leg, I lost first leg 1:2 and must win this one! Starting in 2 hours.
So, he's using this:

http://s18.postimg.org/r703j49ix/111.png

I usually play like this and I'm having great results.
Should I use it against him too?
Looks like I could hold his midfielders and cut passes to the strikers, I would set mentality to
normal and counter attack through the wings.. Tackling hard, own half only.
What do you think?

http://s28.postimg.org/eexki1th9/222.png

Or maybe I should move Gerrard to DMC, remove 1 striker and put in 1 more MC?
It would be like dc,dc,dc - dml,dmc,dmr - mc,mc,mc - st
This way I would totally control the midfield and hopefuly have succesfull wing attacks?