A lot in this game depends on how well your player plays where you put him. Some players do better in one place (left right center or forward v. back) So if your players don't fit into a formation in their best spot it may not work for you.

I use 4 2DMC 1MC AML AMR ST. But My DMC's like that. The offensive minded one gets arrow forward, the other back. I play Defensive, mixed, own half, force counter.

Good Luck!