Quote Originally Posted by Philip L. Willis View Post
I would use a narrow diamond against it, why? It is totally open to all the attacks from the middle, It has no MCs to speak of, no DCs really to stop ND's 2 STs, and especially it doesn't have a center DMC to stop the ND AMC. A Narrow Diamond should if all factors are somewhat equal tear this formation apart.
ND might work. This really depends if the "weird" formation uses "down both flanks" or not. When I use 4-3W-2-1 I run "down both flanks" and it's enough to over-come any formation that is running wings or single DL/DR.