Chek this out. Amazing.

[Yiannis Bresi]

Ok managers out there.
I have 4 accounts on Top Eleven.
lvl 6
lvl 8
lvl 11
lvl 17

After allot crazy results i decade to do the follow test
At the beginning of this season i build 4 identical teams. high quality players according the lvl of each team. same abilities on each team and of course same formation 4-1-3-2 in all teams.

Till today more than half way of running season and never change formation to any of my teams i have the follow results.

lvl 6
Win 35 - Draw 6 - Loss 0
this team playing semifinal on champion league and cup

lvl 8
Win 31 - Draw 6 - Loss 4
this team playing semifinal on champion league and cup

lvl 11
Win 15 - Draw 6 - Loss 9
this ream disqualify form champion league and cup from early much

lvl 17
Win 20 - Draw 7 - Loss 8
this team playing semifinal on champion league disqualify from cup from early much.

In all games so far my teams was stronger or at list even with opponents and of course i had face any formation with 4 of my teams but still non all 4 win.

after all the above i believe the game engine result of top eleven SUCKS.

[Cat Harrison]

What's so amazing? That you won? I don't understand what point you are trying to prove with this.

[BeckStar]

Amazon.

[Panzani]

What's so amazing? That you won? I don't understand what point you are trying to prove with this.

He probably expected to get similar results with his 4 teams

[Benjamin Wolverton]

all this shows is that your strategy sucks and as managers progress and enter stiffer competition, more thought needs to be put into formation and tactic instead of just using 4-1-3N-2 which is similar to 4-1-2-1-2ND which dominates when you fist start out but has a SERIOUS weakness with no coverage on the flanks and will get creamed when facing people using wider formations the more you progress in level

[Yiannis Bresi]

I had face various of formation so far wider, narrow and many others with all 4 teams. If my formation suck explain me way my team lvl 6 and lvl 8 kick arses and my other teams haven't ??

My point to my post was that top eleven game engine sucks.
does any one out there disagree with that?

[Philip L. Willis]

Ok managers out there.
I have 4 accounts on Top Eleven.
lvl 6
lvl 8
lvl 11
lvl 17

After allot crazy results i decade to do the follow test
At the beginning of this season i build 4 identical teams. high quality players according the lvl of each team. same abilities on each team and of course same formation 4-1-3-2 in all teams.

Till today more than half way of running season and never change formation to any of my teams i have the follow results.

lvl 6
Win 35 - Draw 6 - Loss 0
this team playing semifinal on champion league and cup

lvl 8
Win 31 - Draw 6 - Loss 4
this team playing semifinal on champion league and cup

lvl 11
Win 15 - Draw 6 - Loss 9
this ream disqualify form champion league and cup from early much

lvl 17
Win 20 - Draw 7 - Loss 8
this team playing semifinal on champion league disqualify from cup from early much.

In all games so far my teams was stronger or at list even with opponents and of course i had face any formation with 4 of my teams but still non all 4 win.

after all the above i believe the game engine result of top eleven SUCKS.

This was interesting, Kudos, well done.

I think the other posters may be a little bit critical, because of your conclusion that "the engine sucks", it is probably true but not for the reason you have mentioned.

We should try these experiments more often. If you could give more details about this it would be great.

Too bad, we could do this more offend with different formations. But like a poster said your formation is very much a "Through the middle" attack, which at lower lowers tend to destroy opponents, but as you progress the opposing manager is more experienced and will KILL you down the wings.

Tell us more, we are interested.

Peace.

[jacks]

Nothing special. Everyone knows that - higher lvl - higher competition - more experienced opponents. For example when I was 1lvl I just used my best players without care about my formation.

[adr100]

YOU DID NOT BUILD IDENTICAL TEAMS.

THE TEAMS MAY BE SIMILAR (BY COMPARISON), BUT NOT IDENTICAL.

THE TEAMS DID NOT PLAY THE SAME TEAMS WITH SAME FORMATIONS.

THE TEAMS DID NOT HAVE THE SAME LEAGUE, CL AND CUP DRAW.

Bottom line, the game engine may or may not suck, but your "experiment" most definitely did not test it.