if that was with defensive and force counter attacks on then I would say it was not the right call. Switch to attacking with full pitch pressure, and no red arrows on DR and DL and you should be okay. Also for out of player positions I like to think of it as losing 1 star if it is a similar position, and 2 stars if it is a far away position. So if you don't have any other options for players as long as it is a similar position you should be okay. But avoid it in the future