both of you are right ... tho from mine point is quite hard to go through all the posts on forum when every person type formation in different way .....( i mean 3223 , 3.2.2.3 , 3-2-2-3 whatever ) so search forum not working much ... and all is about going through posts manually open post check if its about your formation return check another post and so on .... so its a lot easier to start just new topic for most people

offcourse on how to counter "basic" formation its all about laziness i think ... because they can get answer straight in first post ( Table of Counter Formations v2.0)