This is what I would do. However, I don't know your team or players...

4-1-2-1-2 Narrow Diamond. Attacking/through the middle/whole pitch/hard/short/zonal - no counter/no offsides. Reds on DL, DR, DMC, MC, MC and AMC.

If possible, max win bonus, morale and condition. If you have 2 tokens to spare, use them to make him play 3 hours immediately following his league game so his players will have their condition drained.

Good luck!