So in real life football team (like atletico madrid) can play in same day two matches with same players and second match win against real madrid or barcelona 4-0? i don't think so. Try now in you league play 10 matches with totaly wrong tactis and orders, then post results and we gona see if this game have logic or not i gues you gona win most of matches.
I think the game creators should add some features that team with totaly wrong tactis and completely tired players should lost all the time, because in real life you can't run 15km distance at full speed ant after that win football match against stronger fresh team