Top 3 Overated Formations

[sdw]

Do you mean overrated or overpowered?

Most overrated are 4-5-1 V, WM and butterflies on my opinion. They look kinda fancy so many players use them but in my view they are not as effective as they think, in Top11.

Most overpowered are 3-5-2 or 3-4-3 with some kind of flat midfield, variations. The existence of 2STs provide enough firing power and the 5 midfield players provide too much ball possession without many ways to be countered by game's engine. The same occurs with 3-4-3. Too much power in front with decent possession.
They even allow 3 defenders wide! THAT'S overpowered It should bee too easy to win against a wide backline but it's not as it should be.

Maybe I didnt understand you very well,but I disagree with 3-5-2 and 3-4-3.These tactics are very easy to counter and it's very easy to win against stronger teams than mine.In real life,3-4-3 is very dominant tactic.In top11 3-4-3 and 3-5-2 is easy to counter only with AML/AMR,whatever tactic is.

[Master Tactician]

Maybe I didnt understand you very well,but I disagree with 3-5-2 and 3-4-3.These tactics are very easy to counter and it's very easy to win against stronger teams than mine.In real life,3-4-3 is very dominant tactic.In top11 3-4-3 and 3-5-2 is easy to counter only with AML/AMR,whatever tactic is.

My point is that in top eleven 3 at back are more powerfull than in reality. I don't know, maybe in TOp11 fullbacks are not so essential.Also, a packed midfield give way too much power. Much more than real football.
If your opponent use wingers (AML/AMR) you drop back your ML/MR to DML/DMR and weirdly, you're still fine. Therefore, even if the opponent tries to counter you, you can response quite well. You can just drop 1-2 midfielders or put them higher up and you can pretty much response to he's counter. The real counter would be long balls counter attack and staff like that but again you can still drop 1 MC to DMC and be more solid at back.
That's my feeling. I personally use a variation of 3-5-2 with much better results than I hoped for and each opponenet I've ever met with a variation of 3-4-3 or 3-5-2 did actually pretty well.

[sdw]

My point is that in top eleven 3 at back are more powerfull than in reality. I don't know, maybe in TOp11 fullbacks are not so essential.Also, a packed midfield give way too much power. Much more than real football.
If your opponent use wingers (AML/AMR) you drop back your ML/MR to DML/DMR and weirdly, you're still fine. Therefore, even if the opponent tries to counter you, you can response quite well. You can just drop 1-2 midfielders or put them higher up and you can pretty much response to he's counter. The real counter would be long balls counter attack and staff like that but again you can still drop 1 MC to DMC and be more solid at back.
That's my feeling. I personally use a variation of 3-5-2 with much better results than I hoped for and each opponenet I've ever met with a variation of 3-4-3 or 3-5-2 did actually pretty well.

Now I understood you.Correct,pack of Midfielders is giving you some effort in T11.I dont like the fact that 4-2-3-1 is the best tactic in the world,all big teams are using this formation.But here in T11 this tactic is not so dominant as real.