i'm having a similar problem... keep on drawing to freaking bots that are like 6 quality points below me and i use proper tactics and watch games and make subs and change tactics sometimes to hard attacking and all to no avail... end up having many shots and zero end product and drawing many games 0-0... although i got scout striker with one on one, scout dr with corner and scout mc with freekick and most of my team are 5+ stars... its quite annoying really.... then you got top of the league a player with much inferior team, never watches game or change tactics and u got MvP player that is 3 stars in the league... top scorer is also 3 star.. etc... just too much randomness really... and that whole "tactics" thing i wouldn't buy too much into it and into counter formations really.