I don't like either game to be honest, I've played both FIFA and PES and they are both good in their own way I suppose, I would say FIFA edges it... just. Possibly because FIFA is more of an official game and Manager mode and UT are interesting game modes. I'm just not happy that there is no alternative to either of these games recently.

I used to prefer now defunct football games like Sensible Soccer or This Is Football when that was around.