There is my next opponent in cup. He is two levels higher than me. If you strike two stars out of his players he will only be having a team of 5 and 4 stars players (at his level).

Click image for larger version.  Name: Untitled112.jpg  Views: 24  Size: 68.4 KB  ID: 17074

But my team I had to pay for tokens to get this team.

Click image for larger version.  Name: Untitled113.jpg  Views: 23  Size: 72.6 KB  ID: 17075

Bottom line the cup should be against teams from same level as in League and Champions League.