Quote Originally Posted by HoofDaddy View Post
if you watch the commentary you can usually tell who is having a howler but I like the surprise at the end. Makes the ingame managerial experience that much more fun.
What a load of rubbish!

The comments are shown every 10-15min and barely tell you anything, they are so vague like "Player kicks ball upfield"
Did the ball go to his team or the opposition?
Did it hit the referee?
Did it explode?!

Absolutely useless commentary!!

Real managers do not stay at home doing nothing while the team plays, they watch the game, see who plays well/poor and changes accordingly!!

If you watch the whole game, it should give you the ratings, as if you were there, in real time!!
Ratings would be based on the player performance, passing, tackling, positioning, etc....
If they manage to generate the ratings at the end, they can do it during the game using the same system...

UNLESS the ratings are just random??? Would that surprise you?

Not me, since my goalkeepers can get 4 or 5 when we win 2-0 yet an 8 when we lose 0-2 RANDOM!!