Then the idea-own theory should be that hard tackling work against lower Q teams due that the Quality of our players is high and they don't fail... but as I said.... and like with all things in this game, theres no definitive "studies-proofs", just prophecies lol
yep, that's exactly is my idea and the reason I started this thread, with such details.
Basic functions of the game must follow strict rules, a guide, a manual.
Football and a following game (TE) logic must saying that Normal tackling is the default > Hard tackling should give some more % bonus in your defense but it can cause more injuries and cards > easy tackling decrease some % in your defense but decrease also injuries and the possibility for getting a card no matter is your opponent. if your opponent is a tough team, then you take the risk (with hard tackling) to confront him. If it's an easy team or a game you don't care about, then you set "easy tackling" , to prevent from injuries or cards.
I think that game leaves enough space to play as a good/bad manager as like a good/bad (or inactive) coach too.
If those two are mixed and we add a lot of luck/ roll dice, then it ends like I feel playing lately.
More with my instinct and some info from here and there.