Just wondered why we have to pay tokens to sign on players that come through our own youth system that you have developed, surely you should be able to get both players that come through for free
Printable View
Just wondered why we have to pay tokens to sign on players that come through our own youth system that you have developed, surely you should be able to get both players that come through for free
I asked the same thing this morning, when I saw I had two U21 Players on my team...
This needs a change!
I agree! There should not be any fees for your own youth system, that's why you have a youth system ������������
U21 players consist of one low and one high quality player.
The low quality player is free but high quality is not free why?
Because every player you buy has some value since low quality does not have much value so it is negligible.But high quality U21 is like top players in auction.If you can pay for players in auction similiar you have to just pay 21 tokens in return of money.
Youth is not paying for playing but it is you who have to pay him for playing or he will be having no value.
I think the youth players system needs a change, but I honestly don't know how to do it. :-( :-)
There should not be a token fee to signup your own home grown youth player! The whole purpose of youth system is that you are investing in younger age at your risk, the youth system may generate quality players and it may not. There will be a fee signing a youth into your top 22 squad and that's what clubs do. last youth's production I had was costing me 15 tokens. I cam definitely find an 18 year old in the transfer who I can win for less than 10 tokens.
Also, when you don't want to sign up a youth, I should be able to sell him. I spent 28 days (entire season) working on producing a youth and if I don't pay the 15 tokens, all that waiting is gone wasted. I should be able to sell him even if it's for little money.
Ģood one jondeo.Quote:
Originally Posted by jondoe
Did you guys receive any response from Top Eleven about this matter?
I totally agree that we should not pay tokens to signup our own home grown youth play from our youth academy that we have paid for. I just received today one "high quality" 4 stars player that I should pay 21 tokens to sign up and another very low quality 2 stars with no tokens needed. That's not fair at all. Even if we pay 21 tokens and sell this player, we will not receive back the same amount of money that we can receive if we exchange tokens by money. So, what's the point of this?
Agree with topic starter
Thanks for the suggestions Everyone. :)
This is simply the current design of the system but it doesn't mean that it can't improve. Far from it.
Please continue the conversation and provide some more suggestions.
How would you rework/redesign the Youth Academy?
- A full redesign?
- Just expand on it?
- Just remove the cost of the youths?
- Include extra features that unlock when you upgrade the building?
^ These are just some quick questions as to what you would like to change - if you like them give your proposition, but if you have your very own points/ideas, just shoot! :)
I have some ideas:
1) The youths that you sign up to your squad won't count in that 22 players list (they'll only count after they get to 21 years old).
This would encourage managers to sign up youth players, because it would help them to get better training bonuses.
There should be a limit to that. Perhaps 22 players + 5 youth players, don't really know.
2) The better players that come from the youth system don't have to be free, but they are right know way too costly. I wouldn't mind paying 1 token to sign them (as we all know in order to anyone to bid in the auctions, they have to pay at least 1 token, so i guess that 1 token to sign any player from your youth system is an acceptable cost)
3) We could have an U21 team/squad. We could instead of playing friendlies, train our players in matches between the main squad and the U21 guys. It would be like a friendly, but with less condition loss and a great training bonus to all of the players from the youth. Here in Brazil, at least, i know that there are many teams that train tactics against their U21 or U18 teams. Let's now try to focus on this U21 possibility.
Just remove the fees at all. Improving them to 5* or 6* already costs us a lotQuote:
Originally Posted by Jeeves
If only!Quote:
Originally Posted by runberg
Apparently if you look at the Malaysian clubs, they have a youth team seperated from the main team consisting of local players! That's possible
I actually just want to make reserve squads so if there are too many injuries on the main squad, these youth players should come in handy to prevent 0-3 walkout
I hope that managers will have chance to observe the young players before signing them with tokens, and the they will be encouraged to use their academy players for a certain period. One implementation is creating a young reserve pool of academy U18 players who can be used in friendly matches. These players can be signed with 1 token and lower salary to play before reaching 19 years old. They should be signed with full token cost and salary when they turn 19.
There were a lot old suggestions on youth systems. New administrator may search in this sub-forum if you have time.
Imagine signing a youth player with hard earn 20 or 18 tokens as in my case, would prefer to sign a player of 21-27 with 10 tokens an 9million. This has to change......Dear Managers
Sent from my TECNO F7 using Tapatalk
What about all the good youth players that where throw away because they were expensive (in terms of tokens), what about them? I think this need to change, they should be free of charges because they are from your base.
That´s a great idea I'm surprised nobody has mentioned that beforeQuote:
Originally Posted by Ramonster
I 'm over two years in the forum and don't remember how many posts/threads I 've seen about academy players.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeeves
I would really like to hear the opinion not of a player but some product manager or a dev about that subject.
Someone saying ...
- Yes youth academy is working for us, many players/managers buying their youngsters, they 're pleased and we have big profit from that.
That's why we didn't change the system from the beginning of the game.
Without searching for great, radical or genius ideas , if nordeus just add one more star (and a special ability) to those 4* academy players of 20T, next day they 'll see a ****load of token coming from this feature.
So, I give a penny for their thoughts .
A full redesign
Upgrading the youth system is useless at the moment. We get two players one is 3 stars which we can sign freely and the other is4 stars and with 21 tokens! You should make them both for free(because we already spent alot to upgrade the youth system and then again its from our youth so they should be for free whatsoever) and the 5 star player should have a special ability too. Although then you should make us get 2 youth players a season
I don't think it's out of balance, comparing u21 players with scout list, they are an ok deal just more gamble on skills.
Upgrading tooth camp is same number of days as upgrading grass or scoreboard, so I don't think it's a big investment.
Mostly I just think of Messi - Argentine youth moves to Barça because they can afford medical treatment he needed. Youth aren't obliged to play in home league. Bale could play in the great Welsh league, but then he would never top the pay charts.
make youth like recommandation player you get to choose but in different position 18 6* 79token and 1 free then scrap the recommendation. oh and they alway recommend me goalkeeper from start to end of this season. nordeus you better stop it.