Morale - Take Deux

[cracicot]

Ok now, here are some more stats.

I am not updating the matrix anymore on this thread but I just putting up tables with stats from the matrix instead as these numbers are the relevant things.



These number say something. When I get about 10-15 games worth of stats, they should tell a bit more about the real numbers. Until then I can only say this:

Game stats:

1) Form 5: you always lose morale. Obvious.
2) Form 6: you can actually GAIN moral....but you shouldnt.
3) Form 7: 3 out of 4 players will lose moral.
4) Form 8: less than half will gain morale, which is WRONG.
5) Form 9: you always gain morale.

Daily Maint Stats:

1) 1 in 4 players who played gain morale after daily game maintenance.
2) 5 of your 7 subs will lose morale after daily game maintenance.
3) 1 or 2 of your reserves will GAIN morale after daily game maintenance.
4) Form 5: 50% will lose morale after daily game maintenance.
5) Form 6: Strangely none lost morale after daily game maintenance.
6) Form 7: ~50% GAINED morale after daily game maintenance.
7) Form 8: almost 50% LOST morale after daily game maintenance. WRONG!
8) Form 9: 100% LOST morale after daily game maintenance. WOW! WRONG!

This is just a quick glance. Let me know if I missed anything obvious, or if you can read something into these numbers that I didn't get.

All this to say, Morale seems to be a bit more chaotic than I had thought.

[reddeviljohn]

Ok now, here are some more stats.

I am not updating the matrix anymore on this thread but I just putting up tables with stats from the matrix instead as these numbers are the relevant things.



These number say something. When I get about 10-15 games worth of stats, they should tell a bit more about the real numbers. Until then I can only say this:

Game stats:

1) Form 5: you always lose morale. Obvious.
2) Form 6: you can actually GAIN moral....but you shouldnt.
3) Form 7: 3 out of 4 players will lose moral.
4) Form 8: less than half will gain morale, which is WRONG.
5) Form 9: you always gain morale.

Daily Maint Stats:

1) 1 in 4 players who played gain morale after daily game maintenance.
2) 5 of your 7 subs will lose morale after daily game maintenance.
3) 1 or 2 of your reserves will GAIN morale after daily game maintenance.
4) Form 5: 50% will lose morale after daily game maintenance.
5) Form 6: Strangely none lost morale after daily game maintenance.
6) Form 7: ~50% GAINED morale after daily game maintenance.
7) Form 8: almost 50% LOST morale after daily game maintenance. WRONG!
8) Form 9: 100% LOST morale after daily game maintenance. WOW! WRONG!

This is just a quick glance. Let me know if I missed anything obvious, or if you can read something into these numbers that I didn't get.

All this to say, Morale seems to be a bit more chaotic than I had thought.

Excellent work, looks like you really nailed it!

[Croft Original]

Ok now, here are some more stats.

I am not updating the matrix anymore on this thread but I just putting up tables with stats from the matrix instead as these numbers are the relevant things.



These number say something. When I get about 10-15 games worth of stats, they should tell a bit more about the real numbers. Until then I can only say this:

Game stats:

1) Form 5: you always lose morale. Obvious.
2) Form 6: you can actually GAIN moral....but you shouldnt.
3) Form 7: 3 out of 4 players will lose moral.
4) Form 8: less than half will gain morale, which is WRONG.
5) Form 9: you always gain morale.

Daily Maint Stats:

1) 1 in 4 players who played gain morale after daily game maintenance.
2) 5 of your 7 subs will lose morale after daily game maintenance.
3) 1 or 2 of your reserves will GAIN morale after daily game maintenance.
4) Form 5: 50% will lose morale after daily game maintenance.
5) Form 6: Strangely none lost morale after daily game maintenance.
6) Form 7: ~50% GAINED morale after daily game maintenance.
7) Form 8: almost 50% LOST morale after daily game maintenance. WRONG!
8) Form 9: 100% LOST morale after daily game maintenance. WOW! WRONG!

This is just a quick glance. Let me know if I missed anything obvious, or if you can read something into these numbers that I didn't get.

All this to say, Morale seems to be a bit more chaotic than I had thought.

I Know this is an old thread & you probably don't want to resurrect it, but did you consider Yellow & red cards in your calculations. I had a player with a 2 match ban due to a red card (4 match rating) & his moral went to very poor, I always ensure that my players have superb moral before the match so this was a very big drop, also if a player has more than one position he is able to play in like AMR, MR, MC he may play his best football at AMR getting 9 ratings all the time but playing him in either MC or MR reduces his rating therefore reduces his moral. This theory work for me I have a player DC, DMC if I play him at DC he will get a 9 rating but if I play him at DMC he only gets 7 rating. So on this basis I understand all the work that you have put in but I think that there are a load more variables that contribute to the figures, which may explain odd ones. Good work all the same.

[magic3]

I Know this is an old thread & you probably don't want to resurrect it, but did you consider Yellow & red cards in your calculations. I had a player with a 2 match ban due to a red card (4 match rating) & his moral went to very poor, I always ensure that my players have superb moral before the match so this was a very big drop, also if a player has more than one position he is able to play in like AMR, MR, MC he may play his best football at AMR getting 9 ratings all the time but playing him in either MC or MR reduces his rating therefore reduces his moral. This theory work for me I have a player DC, DMC if I play him at DC he will get a 9 rating but if I play him at DMC he only gets 7 rating. So on this basis I understand all the work that you have put in but I think that there are a load more variables that contribute to the figures, which may explain odd ones. Good work all the same.

OP is banned so you won't get a reply..

[Croft Original]

Thats a shame he had done some good work trying to resolve the moral issue.