How big is the penalty for putting player on position which he's not used to play? Does it hurt ball poss or affects everything from passes to shots?
Printable View
How big is the penalty for putting player on position which he's not used to play? Does it hurt ball poss or affects everything from passes to shots?
5 % for ball possesion. the other effects are difficult to say beacause you couldn't test it. only Game coder know
How do we know this for sure? Where is this info?Quote:
Originally Posted by tongly45
try it once you'll see. permuting 5-6 player and you'll see it clearlyQuote:
Originally Posted by foulmouthbiotch
but 5% is only approx
Have one player in the wrong position but seem not effect much still got much of possession. Maybe effect when put too many player in the wrong position
I agree, I have not noticed any loss in possession at all and I have been playing with 2 players out of position. Love to see some actual hard stats from someone who has actually tested this.Quote:
Originally Posted by onstyle
It's not 5%.Quote:
Originally Posted by tongly45
Maybe it doesnt affect on possession. Maybe the player who plays in wrong place have penalty on his stats.
I'm not so sure, it may be true for most players, or some sort of average, but some it works well for. I would like to test this systematically
of course, so would everybody, but I would agree with the other person who says its probably a personal penalty for the player and not the team, which would make more sense. so tongly45, go back to the drawing board on that one.Quote:
Originally Posted by Cat Harrison
Too many players out of position does effect possession. Don't know the actual numbers, but I played a team with a perfectly legal formation and players were all out of position and possession was 80-20.
I've only obtained 80-20 against illegal formations or legal formations with players in the wrong position.
I've never had 80-20 against a team with a legal formation and players in their correct position.
Maybe it depends on how far out of position the player is? Ive been playing an amc as an aml all season and dont see any effect of possession, though the other day i subbed a striker into rm and my possession dropped dramaticallyQuote:
Originally Posted by foulmouthbiotch
may be you're right, may be not. there is noway to test this effects. you couldn't build 2 player with the same skill and different position. And nothing ensure that the 2 matche has the same stats if you replay it. lolQuote:
Originally Posted by foulmouthbiotch