Just as I thought I had figured out how goalkeepers' performance is rated, this came up....

Click image for larger version.  Name: randomratings.jpg  Views: 30  Size: 97.0 KB  ID: 14392

My gk: conceided 2 goals + made 3 saves = rating 6
Opponent's gk: conceided 4 goals + made no saves = rating 7

Makes you think that ratings are just RNG, doesn't it?