This is a tricky one!, if he was a 50T scout I would say keep him as they tend to play good one season, be average the next then come good again but if he is a scout only in star then it is up to you!, I personaly get rid of the players when their for is consistently poor and go buy another HOT PROSPECT or 18Y but be carefull buying the acadamy younsters on the transfer market, compare the players to other players with the same skill value then only buy the highest priced one as they are more likely to be Norgens.