He played with a 4-4-2 formation, I would have played with 4-5-1 V formation (or maybe I would put red arrows on the ML and the MR), defensive with hard tackling, long passing with one half pressing style and of course with counter-attacks.

Or maybe at least after scoring your first goal you should have played by the strategy above, obviously you were the underdog.
and about the goals, for me it looks normal two attacks two goals.