Why does my team player better defense when I use an attacking mentality???

[pcmacdaniel]

maybe the formation you use suites attack better than defensive but you didn't say your formation so not much anyone can tell you.

I play a lot of different formations, since I like to try and counter what my opponent is doing. Of late, my team has played better defense when I use offense formations, instead of defensive ones, or even normal ones.

I used 4-5-1 V with hard defending, long passing and force counters in the CL (round of 16 - 1st leg) and surrendered 2 goals. Used the same setup in 1st half of a cup match (2nd round - 2nd leg), gave up first half goal; tied it in 2nd half with ND (1-1 final). Went normal in 1st half of league match (4-4-2c formation), gave up 1st half goal, tied in 2nd half with ND (1-1) . All other matches have been attacking. My team has given up a total of 18 goals in 30 matches.

Last season in the cup, I used attacking w/ whole pitch pressing in all matches, even against higher level and higher quality opponents. Faced 7* team in QTRS (1-1, 4-2), faced hybrid 7/8* team in Semi's (2-2, 2-1) and 8* team in final (0-1). Logically, shouldn't more goals be conceded when playing higher quality (in some cases far higher quality) teams if using an attacking mentality? Plus, shouldn't more goals be leaked when using an attacking mentality?

Best answer I've gotten so far (not on this forum - but was from a forum member) is with offense setups, the ball is on the opponent's half and with defensive ones its on my half more.