Can a good keeper be just as efficient 'unscientific test'

**Gert Funck** · 02-18-2016

For the rest of this season and maybe more I will test this player on setpieces.

Reasons:

because its fun
to see if ratings are improveded due to succes (the chicken or egg dilemma) not due to previous form
to see if he scores and assists as much as a SA player.

As you can see, he has no attacking skills. But he loves rushing out, over 200%.

With the new skills on keepers he shouldn't be able to do anything in the attacking role.

My thesis is that it is only a new name for the same skills.

shooting finishing etc.

Rushing out = Shooting
Communication = finishing

I will share his progress through out this season, a period where I am considering quitting this game, that is turning more and more ludicrous

**nikolgiorgos** · 02-18-2016

My thesis is that it is only a new name for the same skills. shooting finishing etc.
Rushing out = Shooting
Communication = finishing

for me this isn't a surprise (as his performance wouldn't affected by those skills).
The surprise as I see it, is how he got such a big difference between those 5 skills (I mean between rushing out and the four others) because the old version didn't allow to have such difference.

**Arion** · 02-18-2016

Originally Posted by nikolgiorgos

for me this isn't a surprise (as his performance wouldn't affected by those skills).
The surprise as I see it, is how he got such a big difference between those 5 skills (I mean between rushing out and the four others) because the old version didn't allow to have such difference.

The rushing out is nearly twice the other skills GK skills.

Fitness is at least 5x the other skills for an academy player Selwyn!!!!!!

**Gert Funck** · 02-18-2016

Originally Posted by nikolgiorgos

for me this isn't a surprise (as his performance wouldn't affected by those skills).
The surprise as I see it, is how he got such a big difference between those 5 skills (I mean between rushing out and the four others) because the old version didn't allow to have such difference.

now lets see how well he does. on corners he has already outplayed players with that SA before he got the last star

**Arion** · 02-18-2016

Originally Posted by Gert Funck

now lets see how well he does. on corners he has already outplayed players with that SA before he got the last star

If he emerges as the Top 3 assist or Top 7 goalscorers, name him Rogerio Ceni.

**Gert Funck** · 02-18-2016

First match went pretty good, although no freekicks. Two corner assist and MVP

Can a good keeper be just as efficient 'unscientific test'-screenshot_2016-02-18-17-34-56.jpg

Can a good keeper be just as efficient 'unscientific test'-screenshot_2016-02-18-17-38-27.jpg

Can a good keeper be just as efficient 'unscientific test'-screenshot_2016-02-18-17-38-50.jpg

Can a good keeper be just as efficient 'unscientific test'-img_20160218_174046.jpg

**talisman** · 02-18-2016

Interesting experiment - Nordeus probably haven't catered for this in their match engine.

"Goalkeeper takes free-kick, defence clears it and immediately an opposition player launches the ball from inside their own half and the ball bounces into the unguarded net"

**Gert Funck** · 02-18-2016

Originally Posted by talisman

Interesting experiment - Nordeus probably haven't catered for this in their match engine.

"Goalkeeper takes free-kick, defence clears it and immediately an opposition player launches the ball from inside their own half and the ball bounces into the unguarded net"

Not the last time I tried it. So guess not